Canada’s banking watchdog flagged a small but vulnerable cohort as renewals piled up
Canada’s top banking regulator used a Montreal conference to deliver a blunt message: a minority of mortgage borrowers face a very rough renewal cycle, even if the wider system remains solid.
“It’s going to be a tough next couple of years,” Peter Routledge, head of the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI), said at National Bank of Canada’s financial services conference in Montreal.
He said the sharpest strain would fall on borrowers whose loan‑to‑value ratio climbed above 80% as prices slipped and whose total debt‑service ratio exceeded 44%.
“Depending on what house prices do,” that group “could be anywhere from about 30,000 to 150,000,” Routledge said.
“It’s really unfortunate for those households.”
Routledge said OSFI expects many of those borrowers to be renewed by their existing lender, but with limited scope to refinance or tap equity.
“Those folks are going to struggle,” he said.
“I believe they’ll be renewed by their lender, but they might not be able to refinance. And we worry about that cohort.”
He emphasized that the numbers remains small relative to the roughly 2.1 million mortgages due to renew over the next two years.
“We think the system has the earnings to absorb that stress,” he said.
“I think the financial system is going to absorb that toughness, not without pain, but without real threat to financial sector resilience.”
Geopolitics, credit risk and a shifting rulebook
National Bank chief executive Laurent Ferreira pressed for a faster response to rising threats abroad. “We need to set politics aside and start thinking about our future, because the world is dangerous,” he said.
To improve national security and economic sovereignty, Ferreira urged Canada to “break down internal trade barriers and to boost energy exports, especially fossil fuels.”
He said the country needs to export more liquefied natural gas westward and move more gas east, adding that “the current political climate also means that everyone should be on board rebuilding defence capabilities,” with Canadian banks “well capitalized and ready to support government efforts.”
Ferreira also raised concerns about Canadian bank oversight tightening while the United States eased rules. “We’ve gone up in terms of supervision, they’ve come down,” he said.
Routledge signalled some openness to recalibration.
OSFI, he said, is “actively working to pare back rules where prudent” and “looking to accept more risk in the system,” including by loosening capital requirements on some commercial lending and accelerating the timeline for admitting new players into the market.
Routledge tied the mortgage challenge to a broader period of “uncharted waters.”
“Our geopolitical environment (has) changed on us pretty dramatically, and I don’t think we’re done with that,” he said.
“There will be costs associated with that and I don’t know how the costs are going to fall. I think they’re going to fall unevenly, and there will be unfortunate victims that don’t survive.”
No systemic crisis, but no comfort for stretched households
OSFI already singled out mortgage renewals and elevated household leverage as top financial‑system risks as a large share of loans came up for repricing by 2026, particularly mortgages originated in the low‑rate pandemic years.
While many borrowers are expected to cope, payment shocks and arrears risks increased, especially in expensive markets such as Ontario and British Columbia.
The looming “renewal wall”is more likely to be a headwind than a crisis, with economists and brokers stressing the importance of early advice and active shopping as rates eased from their peaks.
Make sure to get all the latest news to your inbox on Canada’s mortgage and housing markets by signing up for our free daily newsletter here.
